Policy and practice

Look, I’m not a political theorist – obviously – but I have a strong conviction that lots of people are Doing Politics Wrong and I need to get this off my chest:

In order to cast a vote for any radical change to the status quo, you must support both the policy itself and also the likely outcomes of the implementation of that policy. That is, even the best policy can be neutered or even rendered harmful when put into practice, and so it’s dangerous to vote for a good policy that cannot be safely enacted.

The most glaring modern example of this is Brexit. Many, many people had good reasons for voting for Brexit as policy. (I don’t doubt that many other people voted for Brexit by way of protest or because they didn’t fully understand the consequences.) But even a decade ago, it should have been painfully obvious that the practice of Brexit could only be a disaster. Even with the best possible negotiators and the most brilliant of minds working on the problem, there was still no way of implementing Brexit that would have satisfied even a minority of those who had voted for it as policy. And, in fact, we didn’t have the best possible negotiators or the most brilliant of minds, and so the best-case outcome – which was still pretty bad – was never within reach in practice. This outcome was foreseeable, and many commentators did indeed foresee it, but not loudly or convincingly enough to avoid it.

Last year’s Supreme Court ruling and subsequent EHRC guidance on the provision of single-sex spaces is – rather belatedly, and again entirely predictably – just now being criticised for “not surviving contact with reality“. The policy is well-meaning, at least in terms of protecting one vulnerable section of society. But the practice is “not ready, not practical, and not safe to implement” for another, even more vulnerable section of society.

Today we are repeating this experience with more badly thought-out legislation, which has implications that are all too predictable. I’m referring to the ban on social media for young people. This time, the policy is good and the collective will of the people more clear-cut. Who would dare argue that children shouldn’t be protected from online harms? Who would claim that the mainstream social media platforms are already doing enough to ensure the safety of young people using their services? Who would suggest that children staying in their rooms and doomscrolling on their phones is somehow healthier than playing outdoors or socialising in person?

The progressive media agrees that this is good policy. But this editorial stance doesn’t give anywhere near enough weight to the risks of the implementation.

I will assert this:

  • Requiring every adult to upload government-issued ID and biometrics for every online transaction, or even simply to use a legally-owned computing device, is incontrovertibly a bad outcome for everybody.
  • Mandating every platform provider to scan users’ private files for potentially infringing material is uncontroversially a bad outcome for everybody.
  • Disconnecting people from their support networks and peer groups does not make them safer – a bad outcome for everybody and a devastating one for the most vulnerable and isolated people, including young people.
  • To think that this legislation can be enacted without widespread collateral damage is magical thinking. One might as well pray for a miracle.

The progressive media says, “Some digital rights activists have joined this resistance [to regulation]. They oppose identity- and age‑verification tools on principle, despite the obvious risks to children in an engineered environment that refuses to recognise their age.”

No. Not on principle. Not on policy. On practice. On the entirely predictable reality of how the policy will be implemented.

And that’s even before we get to the detail of the policy position. The inconsistent definitions. The specificity of both the platforms that are weirdly in scope (YouTube, which can be accessed anonymously and which has very legitimate educational and entertainment purposes for young people) and weirdly out of scope (nearly everything outside of the handful of big platforms, even those platforms which are functionally identical). The fact that the network effect means that this year’s bogeyman is not going to be the same as next year’s; that if an entire cohort is unable to connect through one platform, they will very quickly find their tribe on a different one (see: MySpace; Bebo; Friends Reunited; 6Degrees …)

I’m not a political theorist. Nor am I a strategist. But I have to believe that there are better, more effective ways of achieving the legitimate policy goals. Yes, I might vote for the policy. But not for the practice.

Read more

Published
Categorised as Opinion

By David A

Imagination of a poet - communication skills of an engineer. In no particular order, I like old cinemas, Japanese gardens, playing music, giraffes, technology, films, ducks, narrow Italian streets, and trying to write stuff that's interesting to people. I've been blogging irregularly since 2005 and have had some form of website since 1998.