I’m neurodivergent. So what?

Catching up with an old friend recently, she told me: “I’ve been diagnosed with ADHD.” She paused. “It explains a lot.”

I laughed, thinking back on her chaotic student days. I have no doubt that she benefited from – or at least, took some comfort from – her diagnosis. But it changed nothing for me. After all, almost three decades on, she’s still my friend. Whatever unusual or egregious behaviour her ADHD caused, there is nothing left for me to forgive or forget.

Working in tech, I have experienced a higher-than-average number of people who Think Differently. For some, having a confirmed diagnosis is essential, and sharing their diagnosis can really help. Knowing that a colleague is living with dyslexia means knowing how to support them to deliver their best work. Sometimes just by advocating for them, and sometimes by pondering pragmatic tools to make their life a little easier.

Still, I’ve never really been interested in looking under the rock of my own idiosyncrasies. Am I on the autism spectrum or am I just a grumpy, pedantic introvert with misophonia? Who cares? A diagnosis won’t make me less grumpy or less introverted, and my coping mechanisms would remain the same.

To be clear, none of this is intended to detract from the lived experiences and very real issues facing neurodivergent people in the workplace and wide world1. Merely to point out that, for some people with milder symptoms, labelling their way of thinking doesn’t necessarily help.

So it’s a bit of a shock, in the middle of my fifth decade, to discover with certainty that I am neurodivergent and that my condition has a name. What’s more, I only discovered by accident that I don’t experience the world in the same way as most other people. I have aphantasia.

Aphantasia is the inability to voluntarily visualize mental images – a neurological variation that affects how people think, dream, remember, and learn. When someone with aphantasia tries to visualize an apple, a loved one’s face, or a childhood memory, they experience no mental pictures.

Aphantasia.com

I’d never heard of this before, and it’s fairly easy to understand why not: it would never have come up in conversation. It’s not like being severely colourblind, which one would inevitably discover sooner or later, because colours are things that do come up in discussion, or at least in primary school art.

Moreover, aphantasia has only been seriously researched in the past twenty years – so even if someone realised that there was something was amiss, they wouldn’t necessarily be able to name it and nor would a doctor necessarily be able to treat it (although in fact there are some therapies being developed).

I only found out about aphantasia because I happened to read about it in the paper. If I hadn’t been checking my news feeds that day, I might never have known. I might still assume that my way of perceiving the world is the same as everybody else’s.

Actually, it’s entirely possible that I skim-read this 2018 article in the same paper and wrongly came to the same initial conclusion as every other aphantasic: that obviously the author couldn’t have been talking about actually “picturing something”, but merely about a deficit in her imagination.

I couldn’t understand because, in my mind, [book characters] had never been images at all, just concepts. When I shut my eyes, I see nothing. It is black. I have no visual imagination.

Mia Tomova, Experience: I can’t picture things in my mind

Surely, we aphantasics might reason, when other people talk about “picturing something” in their mind’s eye, they mean recalling it to some level of detail – they don’t mean literally picturing it as an image. But that’s exactly what they do. Somewhere between 93% and 99% of people can mentally project an image of anything at all, at will. The rest of us cannot.

Although it didn’t meaningfully change anything at all about my life, this was a profound surprise. I immediately sought to verify my understanding by asking Wifey about her experience. To my surprise, she is also aphantasic and was as bewildered as me by this revelation.

To be clear, being aphantasic does not affect my ability to recall things. I can describe my memories of places and people, sometimes in great detail. I can still get annoyed when a picture seems “off” – when it has been over-processed, or is in the wrong aspect ratio. I sometimes have a vivid imagination – it’s just that I express it in words, thoughts and internal dialogue rather than in pictures. And despite all that, I dream in pictures, and I sometimes have fantastically detailed visualisations in a state of liminal sleep.

But having aphantasia might explain why I’ve never really found mindfulness exercises to be all that effective. Guided meditations that involve paying attention to physical sensations (“Notice the weight in your arms …”) work OK, but those that suggest visualising a particular environment (“Imagine yourself in a forest …”) cannot.

Like any lacked life experience, I am slightly dismayed that I am missing out. But much more so, I am curious about what it’s like for you normies. I have so many questions. And up to 99% of the population could theoretically tell me, but I’m not sure I would be satisfied with their answers.

Perhaps fortunately, more people are becoming aware of this phenomenon. (But I could so easily have missed that article, too; I’m grateful that Molly White posted it on her reading list.) And, yes, more research is now being done. But much of the research focuses on prevalence and therapies. I’m much more curious about lived experience.

So, you picture an apple. What colour is it? What if I asked you to picture a red apple – did your mental picture of the apple immediately change from green to red, or are you stuck looking at the wrong-coloured apple? Was it actually neither green nor red in the first place, but some kind of imaginary colour that doesn’t equate to anything in the real world?

You might laugh at these questions, but I want to highlight that I really have no idea. And I don’t know whether your experience is necessarily the same as somebody else’s, since aphantasia appears to belong on a spectrum (with hyperphantasia at the other end).

Let’s try something more complex. Picture a car. Are you imagining a car or are you remembering a car? Is it a specific model of car? What colour is it? Is it your car? When you picture a car, do you always look at it from the same angle (maybe its left-hand side)? Can you rotate it in your mind’s eye? Can you drive it forward and backward, or make its lights flash? Can you zoom in on details, like the characters on the licence plate or a sticker in the windscreen? Can you see the small scratch on the driver’s door? Was that scratch there before I mentioned it just now? What kind of surface is the car standing on? Can you picture the car upside down? Can you picture the same car but with five wheels instead of four?

If you can close your eyes and picture anything at any time, then why do you take photos? Why do you go to the cinema or to an art gallery?

If I asked you to think back to a place you went on holiday a decade ago – really picture it, in as much detail as you can remember – then what happens to the details that you can’t fully recall? The colour of the carpets; the number of the room? Are they fuzzy? Are they entirely blank? Do you make up whatever details are missing? If you then revisit a photograph of the actual place, can you ever get back to visualising the version in which you inserted your own details?

So many questions.

Epilogue

While I’ve been meaning to write about aphantasia for a while, I have timed this post very poorly (in the sense of it becoming obsolete very quickly). The NYT article has sparked a lot of discussion on social media which actually goes some way to answering my curiosity.

From this MeFi thread – fascinatingly and not entirely unexpectedly:

  • Almost everybody responding has a different experience of being able, or unable, to visualise scenes in their own mind. I could ask my set of questions to a hundred neurotypical people and get a hundred different answers.
  • Some people really can generate entire “movies” in their mind, and replay them, and tweak them as they go along. Some of these are just visual, while other people are able to generate sounds, smells and textures as well. Reality must seem pretty boring in comparison.
  • There are at least as many hyperphantasics as aphantasics, and some of them find their condition genuinely debilitating. For example:
    • being unable to locate a misplaced item because they are equally able to visualise it everywhere at once, instead of recalling where they actually left it;
    • being unable to hold a conversation while driving, because the conversation triggers visualisations that dangerously interfere with the real world.
  • Many – but not all – people with aphantasia also have problems with “face blindness” or cannot meaningfully recall lived experiences, such as holidays, without referring to an external prompt (such as taking copious photographs). Some people are better able to recall the appearance of a close family member from their memory of an old photograph than they are from seeing them every day and may even experience dissonance that their appearance has changed over time.
  • At least one person differentiates between a mental image which is entirely under their control; and an image “projected” onto the inside of their eyelid – which they could still generate, but which was moving and acting outside of their conscious control.
  • Some people with aphantasia find that reading a book is boring because of the lack of visual imagery – at least, compared to watching a film – while other aphantasics actively enjoy the comparative speed at which they can get absorb the narrative without being distracted by what everything looks like.

Footnote

  1. For the avoidance of any doubt, this post is supposed to be about raising awareness of aphantasia. It is not intended to minimise the impact of debilitating neurocognitive differences. I tend to work in a sector that values differences in perspective – including differences in ways of perceiving the world – but I know that’s not true for many people, and in particular, I know how hard it can be for many families who are trying to obtain appropriate education and support for their children. ↩︎

By David A

Imagination of a poet - communication skills of an engineer. In no particular order, I like old cinemas, Japanese gardens, playing music, giraffes, technology, films, ducks, narrow Italian streets, and trying to write stuff that's interesting to people. I've been blogging irregularly since 2005 and have had some form of website since 1998.