Update, November 2023: both services reviewed in this post have changed their subscription tiers and models. Mentimeter has adjusted the restrictions on each level, and AhaSlides no longer offers per-event pricing.
I previously wrote about the critical need for adding audience interaction to presentations – particularly important for remote audiences, but also suited to larger in-person seminars where the presenter would be at risk of losing a direct connection with the audience. Last summer, I used Mentimeter to run a virtual workshop using what I had learned about audience engagement. The workshop went very well and I’ve since fielded many questions about Mentimeter and its capabilities.
To recap what Mentimeter actually does: it provides a PowerPoint-like slide deck with the addition of user interactions. The audience follows along with the presentation on their phones or any other device. Slides can have simple interactions (like, dislike, “I have a question”) or more complex ones, such as a survey or quiz. The results submitted by the audience then appear, in real time, on the presenter’s slides in the form of a graph, word cloud or other suitable graphic. At the end of the presentation, the presenter can download the audience’s responses for further analysis.
It’s attractive, simple to set up and easy for the audience to use.
Mentimeter has a free tier but its pricing ramps up fairly quickly, and has to be paid annually. This puts some severe restrictions on its usage. My workshop absolutely maxed-out the free tier – it would not be possible to make the presentation any more complex. However, Mentimeter has a direct competitor called AhaSlides that has a different set of restrictions.
At first glance, the two platforms are astonishingly similar to one another. The UI is so similar that it’s hard to believe that it’s coincidental. Certainly, if you can use one, then the other will seem completely familiar. But because their free usage tiers differ, you may need to weigh up which is the more suitable for any particular purpose.
There are other platforms, including some that are targeted at educational environments. You may have used Sli.do, which is in a similar domain of enabling audience interaction (albeit deliberately outside of the presentation being delivered). I also tried to evaluate HyperSay, but quickly found its UI to be extremely cumbersome and so I have not persisted.
Here is a quick feature comparison, highlighting the main differences of the free tiers. For both products, advanced customisation and full import / export are premium options only.
Mentimeter free tier
Best for larger audiences but smaller amounts of interactivity. Use this one to bring life to your Tech Talk.
- Unlimited content slides, with simple interactions (“likes” etc).
- Unlimited audience size.
- Limit of seven fully interactive slides, comprising:
- up to five questions in “quiz” format (plus leaderboards);
- up to two other fully-interactive slides such as surveys, Q&A, word clouds etc.
- Attractive templates but very limited customisation options.
- Good selection of keyboard shortcuts for the presenter to control and display the user interactions, including countdown timer options.
- Can export the results as PDF only.
The limitation on interactivity is quite tight, but I largely got around it by using the “like” interactions more often. For example, rather than using up one of my two fully-interactive slides asking the audience a simple “yes / no” question, I put in a static slide with a “thumbs-up / thumbs-down” button that served the same purpose.
AhaSlides free tier
Best for smaller audiences but larger amounts of interactivity. Use this one for the weekly family quiz.
- Unlimited content slides, with simple interactions.
- Unlimited numbers of interactive slides.
- Limit of seven audience members participating.
- Custom URL, like ahaslides.com/MyFamilyQuiz2021
- No templates, but you can upload your own background images and adjust colours to allow for limited branding.
- Presentations can be hidden until it’s time to start presenting.
- Slides can be configured to provide extra information on the user’s device, in addition to what is on the main presentation screen.
- Slightly clunkier interface:
- timers must be set up in advance, and start automatically;
- fewer shortcuts for managing interactions;
- some interaction types don’t register in real-time – only once voting has closed.
- No export options, but can import from PowerPoint.
Unlike Mentimeter, AhaSlides offers a very reasonable one-off event pricing. This makes it viable to use the free tier to build and test a larger presentation, before spending a few dollars to get temporary access to the premium features including the full data export functionality.
For me, Mentimeter has the edge in terms of usability; if I were running workshops regularly enough to warrant a premium licence, that’s the one I’d choose, especially as it has a plug-in for PowerPoint. But as a keen amateur doing a few small workshops and quizzes each year, the free tier of AhaSlides gives me far more flexibility, with a very economical future upgrade path if I need it.
