This week, the APM is running a virtual volunteering forum for participants in its outreach schemes. Their session on effective webinars was yesterday. Normally, I’d wait until they circulated the slides and supporting material before blogging about it, and especially to have time to reflect on the lessons. But the fact is, so many of our normal interactions with our teams and our customers have now effectively become webinars, that these lessons are relevant immediately. This is especially true for product demonstrations, tech talks, and other semi-public forums.
My interest in this topic arises from my volunteering (both with the APM and as a STEM Ambassador), but also from my role as PM of an internal training programme. The training moved from its very nice, very expensive, custom-built classroom to being delivered online-only in the course of 24 hours at the start of lockdown. The plans that we initially put in place were, by necessity, devised in a matter of an hour or so and implemented in under a day. We were extremely fortunate that we already had the requisite tools (for example, Webex for delivery) available for us to use.
Had we designed the programme to be delivered remotely from the outset, there may have been a handful of differences in our approach. But fundamentally, it was about acknowledged experts in their fields delivering presentations, and then supervising project exercises. We never claimed to be experts at teaching, still less at remote teaching. I am incredibly grateful that we found such a good team of effective, knowledgeable teachers, and I am also grateful that our cohorts were so engaged.
By contrast, the APM team aimed to share their experiences of facilitating over a hundred large-scale webinars and virtual conferences – a level of experience we could never have hoped to match.
Their success was mainly centred around the enthusiastic adoption of one particular tool, Mentimeter. Ironically, given that this was a webinar about effective webinars, they did not actually use Mentimeter on this occasion. However, they also shared some more fundamental points about designing and delivering webinars that are independent of the technology chosen.
Interaction always
By far the most important lesson is that the speaker needs to seek regular interaction from the audience. Technology can enable this, but it doesn’t have to be a technical solution.
It takes between three and five minutes to lose an audience. Without interaction, the audience will be looking at their phones or checking their emails. (When this point was raised, I was checking my phone. Whoops.) When delivering a presentation in-person, it’s very easy to judge whether the room is engaged and interested: watch their faces, make eye contact, pay attention to the mood of the room, keep an eye out for people checking the time. None of these clues are as easy on a webinar. Even assuming that your audience has their webcams switched on, you cannot tell whether they are distracted by something else. Even if they’re apparently writing something down, are they concentrating on taking notes or are they creating bored doodles?
Ask questions, and get the audience contributing constantly. Even a simple “hands up” poll forces the audience to pay attention to the speaker. Or use the chat facility to crowd-source the answer to a question.
If possible, set up the presentation to allow for direct demonstration of the topic at hand, and then get the audience to help drive it. For example, it might be possible to build a model within the presentation (perhaps using an embedded Excel workbook) and then the audience could help populate it, seeing the results develop in real time. Or, if the presentation topic is a process, then ask the audience to contribute process parameters and help to drive the stages forward; this will engage the audience’s imagination, as they start to see how they might run the process for themselves, rather than just watching someone else do it.
For a large webinar, engage a behind-the-scenes person to stage-manage the interaction. They can take and moderate questions, and count up poll results, without interfering with the speaker’s flow. If necessary, they can get conversation started by feeding in prepared “soft” questions.
Practice with the technology
Whether it’s Webex, Zoom, GoToMeeting or Skype, it’s essential that the speaker knows how to drive the tool so that it doesn’t get in the way. If in any doubt over whether the screen sharing will work properly, it would be useful to have a second device (such as a laptop or tablet) set up as a “participant” – it will then be easy to spot if the speaker is accidentally sharing her inbox instead of her PowerPoint.
Practice is especially important if the setup is unfamiliar – perhaps working with multiple monitors, for example. If the main laptop has only one monitor and it’s too hard to juggle the presentation material, then perhaps employ multiple devices: one for the presentation, and one for the audience participation.
Also, take time to practice speaking style. Having set up the delivery environment, it’s helpful to record a short clip and learn from it: Is the volume correct or does the sound suffer from pops and breath sounds? Is it easy to look into the camera while also reading notes? Is the lighting comfortable? Is there anything distracting in the background?
Many webinar applications will allow the user to choose a customer backdrop or overlay. It may be useful for all of the speakers in a webinar to set up their backgrounds to be easily identifiable amongst the grid of participant videos – perhaps by using a strikingly visible logo. In any case, more careful thought needs to be given to environment, to create a sense of occasion; there should be a marked difference in approach when addressing a hundred strangers compared with the comfortable familiarity of a team. One person suggested treating the whole presentation as more like a TV show than a video conference: set higher production values and make use of other people off-screen to help manage the experience.
Other suggestions
One person proposed that the speaker should always be introduced by somebody else, as it comes across as less arrogant than a self-introduction. There was a short, interesting debate on gender differences in this regard (as confidence in men is more often seen as a positive trait).
Because it is so easy to lose the audience’s concentration, somebody suggested that webinar presentations should only ever have a single point per slide. This avoids the audience quickly reading all of the slide content and then switching their concentration away while the speaker talks.
The speaker could invite people to stick around after the main presentation, to participate in a more in-depth discussion or follow up on points raised. Somebody commented that this was equivalent to approaching the speaker at the stage after an in-person presentation, or at the bar afterwards.
One experienced webinar host said that the biggest challenge she faced was simply getting people to turn up. So, she suggested, it is a good idea to engage with people both before and after the presentation itself, so that they have an emotional investment in participating fully. Get them to do some short, fun pre-work, such as submitting a drawing of themselves with a fun fact to be shared on a virtual whiteboard. We are used to doing ice breakers at in-person seminars, but not generally at webinars.
Mentimeter
Mentimeter is a cloud-hosted application for hosting richly interactive presentations. (Other similar applications are available.) Think of it as a little bit like Slido on steroids: instead of audience questions or polls disappearing into a different, distracting window, they can appear inside the presentation in real time. Mentimeter allows loads of different kinds of interaction, from simple yes / no votes to complex surveys, with the outputs rendered as graphs and word clouds. All of them are submitted by users on their phones and appear, in attractive animated form, on the relevant slide as soon as they are submitted. Detailed results can then be exported for later analysis. The tool looks to be just as effective for in-person presentations, assuming that the live audience has internet access.
The demonstrations are certainly impressive, although I do worry slightly about the “Zoom Bombing” possibilities of a six-digit access code.
The proposal is that the speaker can make every slide interactive. That doesn’t necessarily mean a full-on survey for every slide. It could mean, for example, that the audience has the opportunity to “thumbs up” to say that they’ve understood a concept, or to ask for more information, or request a comfort break.
It looks great. I know that this is a slightly ridiculous stance based on the briefest of introductions, but it’s hard not to imagine the possibilities for engagement and not get a little bit excited. I cannot imagine the audience would describe something like this as being “death by PowerPoint”.
Final thoughts
There are some practical issues in adopting all of these techniques for an internal audience. But that shouldn’t stop us from striving to make webinars as engaging, interactive, professional, inspirational and memorable as possible.
As it happens, the APM has just asked me to deliver some more volunteering / outreach activities and, frankly, I now cannot envisage delivering a staid PowerPoint, especially to an audience of younger people.
